One main reason Halo 3 was so much fun to ME was due to the ability to either play social or ranked. If I wanted to play split screen with my friend and **** around, great, I can do social. Winning in social didn't mean anything really, losing...meh, "It's just social"
Now.
Ranked is a whole other story. If I lose in ranked I swear, punch my seat, curse the enemy team etc etc etc. If I win it feels great and gets stressful (in a good way) trying to obtain your highest rank. This is what makes Halo, HALO. Ranked games are what seperates halo from CoD. If 343 has the same type of playlists as Reach, ALOT of people are going to be pissed. I will be seriously disappointed due to the fact that winning means nothing in social.
I remember in Halo 3 RANKED TEAM SLAYER whenever the score was 45-40 and you were losing, everyone was franticly calling out, avoiding death, getting focused, pumped and genuine adrenaline was flowing. My heart was beating fast and everyone WANTED to win. That is what halo is all about and if you (343) fail to include ranked you WILL lose so many fans of the series. In Reach...NO ONE gave a wet poop about call outs at all. Why? because all meaning was stripped away with the only option being social.
You may think you are being clever by adding all these new things and changing the franchise, but if you don't have ranked, multiplayer will be BORING. regardless of how good the online gameplay is. Long term competitive players (the REAL fans) will lose interest, like I did with Reach.
In reach you couldn't play with people of your own skill level, just like call of duty. So...do the right thing 343. You still have 6 months to do 1 simple thing that will make A LOT of people happy. Dont **** it up.
peace.