I think you're right Undead, Far Cry 3 is looking like good GOTY material. I guess there's no way to know right now anyway but it's fun to speculate. Honestly, my biggest concern for Halo 4 is the soundtrack over anything else. And it's not so much of a concern as it is curiosity, I just want to hear some new Halo music.
How exactly is the Game of the Year chosen anyway? Is it a democracy or a behind the curtain type of thing?