Well, this is my first post ever on this forum (I used to be on Bungie.net all the time back in the good ol' Halo 2 & 3 days). I made an account here specifically because I have concerns about the playability of the Default, Fishstick (CoD), and Green Thumb control schemes in particular.
Before I begin my rant, I would like to ask that anyone who has relevant information or knows that this feature is already in, please let me know by posting in this thread or PM me so that I can stop bothering people about this. I may simply be misinformed. If they already have it on toggle, just let me know, there's no need to flame/spam hate messages/call me a noob, etc. On the surface it seems like a minor detail. Also please don't post any garbage in here saying that I want Halo to be like CoD just because I want some similarities in the control setups, because I don't even like CoD. Trust me, that's the absolute last thing that I want to happen. What I am asking for is in many of the world's top-rated FPS games, not just CoD but also the Battlefield and Borderlands series, to name a few.
Here's my two cents: Any control setup that has sprint on a face button is automatically inferior and practically unusable in my opinion, this ain't Gears of War. I am a very aggressive player and I am always on the move, preferably sprinting as much as possible. Having to constantly shift my thumb back and forth from the right stick to a face button is unacceptable for a Halo game, which in competitive play requires lightning-fast reflexes and extreme dexterity to succeed. Therefore, three of the seven control schemes that have been revealed thus far are undesirable to me. Southpaw is also eliminated as being my chosen setup for obvious reasons.
I have now narrowed my selections down to three possible choices: Default, Fishstick, or Green Thumb. One of the strong points of the entire Halo series (even including Halo Wars!) is the smooth, fluid, and intuitive feel of the controls. But there's a possibility that Halo 4 will bring an end to this illustrious legacy of great controls. This is the point I've been trying to get across with this post:
:wallbash: IF WE ARE FORCED TO CLICK & HOLD DOWN THE LEFT STICK OR USE A FACE BUTTON TO SPRINT, THEN YOU SCREWED UP BIG TIME, 343. END OF STORY.
Keep in mind that the Default control scheme has sprint on the left stick. If I were asking for a feature to be added that would only benefit some strange off-the-wall control scheme then I could understand why you wouldn't put it in. But this is the DEFAULT we're talking about here. If anybody would like to simply get a general idea of how bad that would suck, try loading up Skyrim and re-map sprint to the left stick. It's one of the most uncomfortable control settings to use that I've ever tried, not to mention the extreme wear-and-tear it would inflict on your controller after prolonged use.
Please fix it, make it so that the Default, Fishstick, and Green Thumb control schemes are either A) set up as toggle automatically, or add an option for sprint to be set up for toggle or hold, just like crouch is. If you gave us that ability for zoom as well, I'd be thrilled, but zoom doesn't need the option nearly as badly as sprint does. Now, if this is already the case, and I am just uninformed, I guess I just stuck my foot in my mouth (or in my keyboard?) 343 Industries, you have the time, but will you put in the effort? I will be heard!
P.S. 343, you already know this, but practically everybody wants fully customizable controls. Bethesda can do it, so can you. Just use the power of Grayskull.
==============================
HALO 4 CONTROL SETUPS (Originally posted on MLG Forums and is subject to change)
==============================
DEFAULT
LT – Throw grenade
RT – Fire Weapon
LB – Use Armor Ability
RB - Melee
LS – Movement/Sprint
RS – Look/Zoom
A – Jump
B – Crouch
X – Action/Reload
Y – Switch Weapons
Dpad – Select Grenade (left or right)
================================
FISHSTICK
LT – Zoom
RT – Fire Weapon
LB – Use Armor Ability
RB – Throw Grenade
LS – Movement/Sprint
RS – Look/Melee
A – Jump
B – Crouch
X – Action/Reload
Y – Switch Weapons
Dpad – Select Grenade (left or right)
================================
GREEN THUMB
LT – Throw Grenade
RT – Fire Weapon
LB – Use Armor Ability
RB – Zoom
LS – Movement/Sprint
RS – Look/Melee
A – Jump
B – Crouch
X – Action/Reload
Y – Switch Weapons
Dpad – Select Grenade (left or right)
================================
RECON
LT – Throw Grenade
RT – Fire Weapon
LB – Use Armor Ability
RB – Action/Reload
LS – Movement/Crouch
RS – Look/Zoom
A – Jump
B – Melee
X – Sprint
Y – Switch Weapons
Dpad – Select Grenade (left or right)
================================
BUMPER JUMPER
LT – Use Armor Ability
RT – Fire Weapon
LB – Jump
RB – Melee
LS – Movement/Crouch
RS – Look/Zoom
A – Sprint
B – Action/Reload
X – Throw Grenade
Y – Switch Weapons
Dpad – Select Grenade (left or right)
================================
BOXER
LT – Melee
RT – Fire Weapon
LB – Use Armor Ability
RB – Throw Grenade
LS – Movement/Crouch
RS – Look/Zoom
A – Jump
B – Sprint
X – Action/Reload
Y – Switch Weapons
Dpad – Select Grenade (left or right)