Here's the thing....People dissagree on this because H1, 2, 3, ODST, and Reach are all different. Some players tend to play better or worse depending on the type of gameplay. Some people LOVE Reach and the AA's, they are the ones that can play well with them, some people hate them, this is because you cant play reach like you play H2 or 3. Same thing the other way arond, you cant play H3 like you play Reach, you will get owned. It took me a while to get used to Reach....and when I play H3 after playing reach for an extended period of time, I suck big time on H3. I love all of the games, even ODST and Halo Wars. I think thats because I accept them for what they are and dont make a debate about what one title has and one other one doesnt. I would like to see H4 be something new and exciting. Does everyone want just another H3 with some new maps? or, would you like to see something innovative and fresh for a superior gaming experiance? The one thing I dont want is Halo to become COD, new game every year, same old game with some new Multi-player maps.