Are you kidding me? I saw more emotion from a Moa on Reach, than Master Chief throughout the entire series! Talk about bland, even the ending to halo 4 had little to no emotion. it was all one sided with Cortana.
Halo 3 at the time did play great, but it wasn't until going back to earlier Halo's and halo Reach that we actually saw how slow and sluggish the gameplay really was. Halo 3 suffered from a lot of the same issues Halo 2 did in terms of geometry and repetitive feelings in the levels. Halo Reach beats it hands down. The environment were more varied and more open ended. AA's are just equipment, with more than one singular use. Reach also allowed players to choose the weapon they were most comfortable with in multiplayer, rather than always being at a disadvantage cause your not one of those OMFGIMSUCHAHARCOREPROCAUSEIOWNWITHABATTLERIFLEORDMRANDTHATSALLICANDO person. For the first time, players had to out think their opponent cause players were put on a more even battle field due to being able to choose their starting most skilled with weapon. You can argue that all you want, but if your really so pro, why do you need your opponent to start with the same weapon as you, if you clearly have the advantage cause your better with it?
Also Halo Reach's campaign felt a lot longer than Halo 3's. It had a much better story telling aspect. I don't see why people cannot appreciate the story. Sure it was dark and fated, but that's the point. To show how Reach fell. What were you expecting?
And Johnson's death being emotional? Please.... Watching Kat get shot in the head and showing her fall as they grab her in slow motion, was much more emotional. Guess your too young to appreciate the subtle things like that. I guess screaming is what you call emotional.
Oh and about vehicles? More? Please, don't try to count the Elephant. You couldn't drive it. Reach had 1 less vehicle...Hardly able to boast it having much more. 1 does not make or break.
Halo 3:
Warthog, Wraith, Mongoose, Ghost, Scorpion, Prowler, Chopper, Hornet, Banshee
Halo Reach:
Warthog, Wraith, Mongoose, Ghost, Scorpion, Revenant, Falcon. Banshee
Overall halo Reach for me was a better game and a much better story telling experience.