The only way it'd be my "perfect Halo 4" is if they remade Halo 2 and called it Halo 4.
I just haven't been happy were Halo is going, ever since they slowed down the combat in Halo 3, I've been a sad puppy. And all the AA's and other bull**** they do to freshen the game up ain't doing it for me. My "competitive hunger" has been a gaping hole for 4 years and running.
Sorry I have become a little jaded with the Halo series.