This is a terrible thread, but reading it just dumb founded me to how ignorant the "casual" gamers are.
Say I play football casually for my local town, Now if the NFL were going to make some rule changes to their sport. Do you think they would much rather take the opinion of their PROFESSIONAL players, rather then myself and my buddies who just play casually for fun.
This is not saying that the PROFESSIONALS will always make the best decisions, but sure as hell they know alot more about what their talking about then a bunch of casual players.
You seem to think that the competiive community are trying to take the fun out of the game.... Do you really think they would play Halo if it wasn't fun?
They would not be putting in all these hours of gameplay if they didnt love Halo and they would much rather see it be the best game ever rather then die off.
Maybe you should step back and let those people who are highly commited to this game make it into something better. Their is always room for improvement with anything.
Maybe instead of being totally against what these "Pros or competitive gamers" are putting forward you should maybe say: yeah that sounds good but maybe try tweaking it a little this way, rather then just outright saying no.
So my conclusion is, you should still voice what you think is going to make the game better, but maybe take into consideration that some of these guys pushing for more competitive settings are highly towards improving the game.
Also to add on to my previous comment, your first line about wanting the same old levels rather then new ones. I bet a race car driver would like to see the Nurburgring on the racing schedule every year due to the fact it is a brilliant track, why can't you do the same for a Halo level.
Of course if some new brilliant levels come in that can replace the great old Halo maps, then yeah... we would'nt need them in matchmaking. But it would allways be nice to play on your old favourite map everyonce in a while.
Have you ever been on a holliday to the same place twice? If so... you're a hypocrite. Travelled the same way to work because it's simple the best way? Well again, You're a hypocrite
Wanting to do the same thing over and over again because its fun, the best or whatever reason you like it for, should'nt be condoned against.
I would like to play on some of the best old Halo maps, but also play the new ones. I don't see how you could be against it, You just seem to want to oppose against what other people want rather then come to an agreement somewhere in the middle