So many people don't play it. I don't know the exact numbers but im pretty sure that there's only like 100,000 playing at one time. It has less people than any other halo game by a large margin(not presently, but comparably for each game's time period). If they want to make a game that fun to play just to play, then they are going about it all wrong because then there is no way they are going to compete with cod or better yet bf3. People who want to have a "cod" experience can just go play cod. IMO what makes a game fun is a game that's competitive. But if i had a couple of drinks and wanted to get on a game with friends, my first choice wouldn't be halo, no matter how noob friendly it is. They aren't going to get cod players to convert unless they were previously halo players because a new cod comes out every year and they will go buy and play that. So i guess the 100,000 people (or so(not sure)) that still play(besides halo pros), play it for the fun; and the millions that stopped playing played for different reasons(competitiveness, the "halo" feel, weapons,ranking,w/e). Recognition is the best motivation.I agree with pretty much everything else you said.