Hanging 1
Slowly, Caboose walked up towards the noose, being spat on as he did by all the villagers around him. "Skin him!" Shouted Connor. "Flay him alive!" Axilus Prime yelled. "Skin him, then flay him alive!" Fox McCloud suggested.
Two guards walked up, and yanked a rope quickly around Caboose's neck, before trying it into the noose that would send him to his death. There would be no more votes coming from him now, unless the dead could affect the living.
The GM chuckled, musing that this was Mafia, after all. The dead could certainly affect the living.
Even still, as he held the reaper's scythe within his hands with a twirl, he walked up with a scroll of exactly what had happened when Caboose had decided to do whatever it was he'd done. Some of the information though, would have given away some roles, so all the GM could do to keep it fair was to say what Caboose tried.
"My Dear not-really-my-friend Caboose, you are hereby here today to be hung by the village, lynched for your attempts at causing chaos." "Stupid Mafia!" Somebody shouted. The GM wondered if they guessed wrong.
"You began the game with everybody already somewhat mad at you from out-of-game stuff. Not that I care - bloodlust is just more fun. But the moment you got more votes than JXZAW, you panicked immediately. And what is the first thing a Mafia shouldn't do?" The crowds of people all mumbled at once: "Don't panic." "That's right," The GM continued, before taking a look at his scroll. "You then attempted to threaten your Mafia teammates, saying that if they didn't vote for JXZAW to save you then you would reveal who they were. Not really a team player, are you? And yet you question why you were voted to be hung. Nonetheless, you continued to panic, and decided to claim that you had been PM'd by a Mafia to help save him. You yourself were the catalyst for shattering that plan - you panicked more, and somehow forgot that one day isn't two days. Tadah. You reveal yourself as Mafia, much to the chagrin of those in your Mafia PM." He took another look at the scroll, before raising his head back to address the people. "Your plan now a pathetic attempt at living that you practically destroyed yourself, you resorted to claiming that other people are Mafia to see if that somehow saves your own skin, or something like that. You also gave evidence to show that everything that had happened in Scene 1 was 'planned'. If it was, AWESOME. Then Pro-town has some great players. If it wasn't, then Pro-town was very lucky." "Because in Scene 1, The medic (randomly?) protected Connor, probably thinking the Mafia would try to assassinate the assassin just for the irony, while the Detective investigated you, Caboose. But that matters no more - your role will now be for everyone to see." Deathscythe in hand, the GM shook his head in mock disappointment. "Either way, the only thing this showed to me was bad teamwork. So I guess this might be a good thing for whichever team you're on - one more Feeder off your team." He swung his scythe, slapping a big red button that immediately opened the door beneath Caboose, who fell downwards immediately. There was a snap as his neck broke.
"Awwww," Caboose's corpse muttered, "Now I'm dead."
Caboose the Ace, Mafia, Lynched.
All players with roles (Mafia, Medic, Detective), PM me your targets for night 2 ASAP.
EDIT: Okay, here's the tip. Common sense should have told you this already (Especially you, Caboose, because this was one of the factors that gave you away), but Connor Kenway is innocent. [Note - This is only for this game - in other games different varieties of roles could mean he wasn't innocent. But here, there are only Mafia killers, and everybody else is innocent, so yeah.] He was attacked and saved, but even if he was dead or alive it doesn't matter. He is proven innocent. This means that roles like the Detective and the Medic can PM him, and use him as a conduit to talk to each other or figure out who is who through screenshots and whatnot. Villagers can do so as well to know who the roles are, and who the roles think they should vote for. But beware, for the Mafia can fake up screenshots and PM Connor as well.
Logic.
Have fun.