Well...that was a complete disaster. At least we didn't have any more civilian deaths this round as we would have if the medic guessed wrong.
Seeing as Oar was innocent, I need to more carefully review people's actions before accusing. From re-reading JL's posts it now seems like he is most likely. He normally takes a very proactive role. In one game he PM'd me telling me to assemble a group to counter the Mafia, and he was rather...pushy...about it.
This game, though, he has done nothing of the sort, even saying he has better things to do. Might those better things be murdering us all?