Jump to content

I_Make_Big_Boom

Legendary Members
  • Posts

    1,781
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    117

Everything posted by I_Make_Big_Boom

  1. Hayley Kenway is a Mafian. Vote for EK. I vote for Hayley Kenway. 1-2 Mafians can be on a Suspect List at a time.
  2. That is not needed. We already know he has a high chance of being Mafia, and I'm not hiding from the fact that I'm a target as well. We need the Detective to pay attention to investigating people who aren't already, or nearly already confirmed. I CAN get the Psychic to investigate him though. I'm not sure if they'll agree to do it or not. EDIT: Wow they responded quickly, and agreed to do the deed... my suspicions are proven correct. Hayley Kenway is a Mafian Henchmen. Proof:
  3. The only role that has the power to stop a Lynch is the Mafian Don. Why would they stop the Lynch now? I'll tell you why: it's because one of us (EK or SD) is a Mafian, or BOTH of us are Mafians. Stopping the Lynch was the only way to save the Mafian from certain death. I suggest we persecute both SD (me) & EK in any Lynch in the future.
  4. Gears of War: Ultimate Edition comes with 4 360 Gears games - http://343i.org/348

  5. It keeps people who are possible Special Roles, or Civilians from dying because of uncertainty, and I become a safe haven for Special Roles who want to have a voice in the thread, but cannot due to not having enough security & or an "Agent" of sorts (if the Role is willing to work with you). I've made this approach in multiple games to good effect. I believe I would be more useful dead than alive. Being a Civilian sucks.
  6. Kittens, I found an inconsistency in the Thread. The number of Protowns is 9 when there's actually 8 of them.
  7. But we DID vote. You're telling me 4 votes = 0? In the past null usually means we're voting for the option for no one to die (Null), unless I'm remembering incorrectly. It's alright if it was changed, but telling us NOW of all times seems a little weird to me. Whatevs. I guess I'll volunteer to die to become the friggin Mediator again (this is like the 5th time I've done this). Vote for Self Destruct.
  8. Wait what? Null has more votes than either me, or EK... does that mean it's not an option? Why didn't you tell us this beforehand?
  9. Oh ok so everything we're doing right now is Mafian manipulation. Sure, deceive yourself into believing that. I think the only one here who's being irrational is you, Caboose. You want results & to narrow the list? Vote me out. All of you. I can't believe I've had to resort to this for more than 1 game.
  10. If 1-2 Mafians show up per Lynch you can figure out who could potentially be a Mafian via Scene Deduction. 1: Scene Deduction 1-2 Mafians show up per Lynch (unless it's different this game). So that would mean if 2 people on that list were confirmed via other means, and are NOT Mafia the other two people are immediately candidates for being Mafia. If 3 out of the 4 players are confirmed beforehand, and are NOT Mafia then the last player is a Mafian. Imagine it as pieces of a puzzle that's slowly coming together. 2: Psychic They can investigate a player like the Detective every 2 Rounds. The problem is that they're a Neutral, and it might be a problem to get them to join the Protown cause. You also cannot trust them at all due to their Neutral status (you shouldn't trust anyone unless they're confirmed). 3: Slipup Certain events lead a player to be revealed as Mafia via a slipup by the Host, or something the Mafian does that's telling of their role. Like a Mafian revealing themselves (like EK did in a previous game), or them frantically doing "damage control" in the thread to change the outcome of a big event to follow. You usually did your own grave by trying to get everyone to vote for someone else besides you in a Lynch. 4: Cracking This one takes some analyzing to do. This involves proving if certain member's evidence is true, and if they'e actually legit, or wrong from what they claim. You have to put on your Detective glasses for this, and it's not something that happens often. EK gave me a sketchy screenshot in a previous game, and I figured out that it was a fake. This led him to reveal his role to me like I said up there ^. The results are slower than a Lynch, but they do come eventually. You just have to be patient.
  11. I don't see significance in voting tendencies. It's too random for me to gauge. Give me a detailed list of why voting is good.
  12. Agreeing to not lynch is what a mafian would say. You're now my #1 candidate for Mafia. Agreeing to not Lynch would make us Mafians? In what world is that a good conclusion? We all came to an educated agreement, and followed through with said agreement in the effort to prevent needless death. We kill someone, that ticks off one more person on the list of who is who. It narrows down the list, I don't see the benefits of voting null except giving the mafians the advantage. You could easily do this for Executions. We DON'T need more death than what we already have. That's an obvious benefit right there. I'd rather vote for someone that we KNOW is Mafia then do roulette hoping to make it big, and then claiming the death of a Protown is a "good thing" for the advancement of the Protown cause: trying to make good out of a bad decision. It really isn't. That person is now dead, and probably will leave the game forever, and the Mafians now have 1 less person to deal with, and 1 less potential Protown / Neutral Role to worry about. It's a double edged sword. Yes, we do mark off who's who as the people fall, but on the other hand we start losing people, and the Mafians become ever closer to victory. I was willing to sacrifice people in the past to "help" us out, but that strategy has worked wonders for Protown (it hasn't), so I think it's time we try something else. You're just going to have to be excluded for being a faithful traditionalist. Oh, and I plan on doing those "Game So Far" things so it's not like we're holding up Mafia by doing this. There will still be deduction, but not at a pace that's dangerous for Protown. Remember in 10.0 Bnus tried so hard to get everyone to vote null, why did he do that?! BECAUSE HE WAS MAFIAN! So we're in the wrong just because we want to keep wasteful death out of Mafia? We're guilty? Riight. Says the person who's willing to kill innocent people every game to win. That mindset actually should be of a Mafian, but unfortunately it's what everyone's been doing for the last few games (it was a trainwreck in 13.0, admit it). I change my vote to Sd so we actually might stand a chance of killing someone. PLEASE DONT VOTE NULL! You are only playing into the mafians hands by doing this! You're only enabling the Mafians by doing this. Make them starve for kills, and they'll screw up to try to close the gap (which is probably what they're doing now, and by "they" I mean you). But you can vote if you want, I'm not stopping you. I'm just encouraging everyone to think about the ramifications of what your actions do in the game. Think about the big picture. We're going to have to play smart if we're going to win.
  13. I think it's time that Protown tries to save lives instead of taking them, yea? We can deprive the Mafians of 2 kills in a Round if we can control the Lynch.
  14. I'd be more forgiving if there was motive behind this. I really hope people aren't throwing around their votes just to see what happens, and have no proof to back it up. I don't want to be like "Yo don't kill me" 'cause then everyone would think I'm trying to weasel my way out, and that would mean I'm probably a Mafian (due to some form of deduction).
  15. I don't see why I am the most popular option here. I literally have nothing that could prove that I'm guilty. I'd like to see some proof... unless this is more of the mindless voting we all do. I suspect that anyone who's voting for me could potentially be Mafia. I usually get killed off early in the games (why do I get the feeling like everyone thinks I'm a big threat?).
  16. What do you use to make those preview images? Good work btw.
  17. Posting who the Medic protects is a good addition. Now we know if they're actually doing their jobs or not. DON'T do it for the Detective though. Dumpen9 apprently is a Neutral, and I'm a Civilian (unconfirmed), so that leaves Church & Kenway. Church has been afk, so I'm going to vote for EK.
  18. -2000 I won't reveal my role so the REAL Mafians can't go "Ok SD isn't who we thought he was, move along, time to metal detector for the critical Protown Roles".
×
×
  • Create New...