Personally, I am getting the PS4. Both consoles pretty much have the same Specs, but in my opinion, PS4 has the better exclusive games.
PS4:
Daylight
DC Universe Online
Deep Down
Don’t Starve
DriveClub
Final Fantasy XIV
Galak-Z
Infamous: Second Son
Killzone: Shadow Fall
Knack
Mercenary Kings
Octodad: Deadliest Catch
Outlast
The Order 1866
PlanetSide 2
Ray‘s The Dead
Secret Ponchos
The Witness
Transistor
Xbox One:
Forza 5
Halo 5
Killer Instinct
Minecraft One
Crimson Dragon
Dead Rising 3
Sunset Overdrive
Quantum Break
Ryse
Titanfall
D4
The PS4 is $100 cheaper. One big reason is that the PS4′s attachable camera, a rough equivalent to Xbox’s Kinect, is sold separately for $60. I’d prefer to have the choice and save the money.
Microsoft is justifying the $499 price tag of the Xbox One by flagging the inclusion of Kinect as standard, while Sony is sticking to offering the PlayStation Eye as an extra peripheral (priced at $59). I’d argue that most gamers have no interest in motion-control, so cramming it down people’s throats is actually a bad thing. This difference in approach also suggests the PS4 is the console of choice for core gamers, with the Xbox One clearly embracing the casual crowd.
I really don't want a new Halo. I want something different. Something new. Games like Uncharted, The Last of Us, and Infamous are all great games. I can play Titanfall on my PC.
Microsoft only changed some of their problems because they saw what Sony was doing and how they were dominating them in pre-order charts.
PS+ seems more reliable and has a lot of better features than Xbox Live, imo.
I can also use the extra $100 I'm not using on the Xbox One for a new game and/or controller.
All I saw at E3 for Microsoft was "TV TV TV SPORTS SPORTS TV, and... Call of Duty: Ghosts."
These are all just my OPINIONS. I love Halo, and I play that 93% of the time on my 360. But I mean, come on. Its not the Halo I grew up with anymore. Halo 5 looks promising, but so do a lot of the other Exclusive games on PS4.
You have some good points, and i may buy an Xbox One when Halo 5 comes out, but PS4 is my choice for now.