Mafia 5.0

[Buns]

Its pretty obvious Prime is Mafia. He keeps trying to deny Yoshi is medic when TWO confirmed innocent are saying otherwise. 

[Axilus Prime]

I'm not actively attempting to deny anything.

 

I do, however, need to see the same proof that these confirmed innocent have seen in order to believe him. I have seen absolutely nothing to indicate that he is pro-town, let alone the medic.

[Akali]

Yoshi is medic. How do I know? I'm Mafia

[Composite Armour]

I'm not actively attempting to deny anything.

 

I do, however, need to see the same proof that these confirmed innocent have seen in order to believe him. I have seen absolutely nothing to indicate that he is pro-town, let alone the medic.

You're mafia.

[Akali]

You're mafia.

Nah trust TD

[I_Make_Big_Boom]

Its pretty obvious Prime is Mafia. He keeps trying to deny Yoshi is medic when TWO confirmed innocent are saying otherwise.

 

I'm innocent and I don't know who the Medic is.

 

I love how everyone is attacking Axilus when JL can easily be the Mafian too. They wouldn't both be on that 1st lynch list for nothing.

 

And I know I'll get "JL had proved himself to be Pro Town" or "JL isn't Mafia" comments. Did it ever occur to you that he could be playing you? JL is a pretty smart kid. Of all people here I think he could pull off being Mafia without anyone suspecting it.

 

The safe route would be to lynch both Axilus and JL. Game over, Civvies win, Mafians suck, Mafia 6.0 begins shortly.

[Delpen9]

Busn said it was pretty obvious that Blake was mafian, but look where that got us. 

I just want to put this out there because it's funny. 

[I_Make_Big_Boom]

Busn said it was pretty obvious that Blake was mafian, but look where that got us. 

I just want to put this out there because it's funny. 

 

But... Busn is always right :c

[Axilus Prime]

Well, unless Yoshi's the Mafian, in which case I say we lynch him and JL. He accused me right from the start with no grounds whatsoever. He didn't even try to support his statement in any way, he just kept at it.

 

And now, when I have stated my grounds for him being Mafia, it's funny how no one provides a proper defense. The closest thing to it is people saying that confirmed pro-town think he's the medic. Well, confirmed pro-town have believed a Mafian to be the medic and even the Detective in past games. Confirmed pro-town have believed innocents to be Mafia more times than can be counted. The word of a player alone means nothing unless backed up by evidence, be it in the person's behavior, or other means.

 

Therefore, I must see the proof they claim exists directly on my own laptop, or I have no reason to believe he is anything other than Mafia.

[I_Make_Big_Boom]

Well, unless Yoshi's the Mafian, in which case I say we lynch him and JL. He accused me right from the start with no grounds whatsoever. He didn't even try to support his statement in any way, he just kept at it.

 

And now, when I have stated my grounds for him being Mafia, it's funny how no one provides a proper defense. The closest thing to it is people saying that confirmed pro-town think he's the medic. Well, confirmed pro-town have believed a Mafian to be the medic and even the Detective in past games. Confirmed pro-town have believed innocents to be Mafia more times than can be counted. The word of a player alone means nothing unless backed up by evidence, be it in the person's behavior, or other means.

 

Therefore, I must see the proof they claim exists directly on my own laptop, or I have no reason to believe he is anything other than Mafia.

 

+ Civvies

/ Unconfirmed

- Mafia

 

Suspect list:

Axilus Prime /

OneOarInTheWater +

Ignited Bullet /

Blake Belladonna +

 

There was no Mafian voted out that round, so the single Mafian... who is still alive... is either JL or Axilus. NOT TheSilverCenturion or Yoshi.

 

Time to die. You and JL both.

[Composite Armour]

Well, unless Yoshi's the Mafian, in which case I say we lynch him and JL. He accused me right from the start with no grounds whatsoever. He didn't even try to support his statement in any way, he just kept at it.

 

And now, when I have stated my grounds for him being Mafia, it's funny how no one provides a proper defense. The closest thing to it is people saying that confirmed pro-town think he's the medic. Well, confirmed pro-town have believed a Mafian to be the medic and even the Detective in past games. Confirmed pro-town have believed innocents to be Mafia more times than can be counted. The word of a player alone means nothing unless backed up by evidence, be it in the person's behavior, or other means.

 

Therefore, I must see the proof they claim exists directly on my own laptop, or I have no reason to believe he is anything other than Mafia.

Both me and SD posted evidence that Yoshi or Mayhen cannot be mafian.

[Delpen9]

I think it doesn't matter. There's no way for the mafian to win. 

[Axilus Prime]

Me and Ledge personally saw the PM

This.

[I_Make_Big_Boom]

This.

 

It doesn't really matter if we (or the people left alive to be more exact) decide to kill you both this round. It would be the smart thing to do. The dumb thing to do would be to vote just 1 of you out.

 

BUT, like you, I would like to see the evidence showing that Yoshi is the Medic. Not like it matters since the game is pretty much over anyway.

[Composite Armour]

I'll show you the evidence that Yoshi is medic when the game is over.

[Yoshi1176]

Axilus, I'm Medic, and there is about four or five confirmed Civies that know, you keep trying to make me look like I'm Mafia when I'm clearly not. So even if you aren't Mafia you made yourself look like it. congrats.

[Delpen9]

How Axilus could be a Mafian:

He killed Ledgend because he thought Yoshi was subterfuge; this would all make sense with Ledgend's unexpected saving in round 1. Ledgend may have been saved by the medic at first, but the possiblities lie in the medic defending himself. Attacking Yoshi would mean a waste of a round, and leaving him alone would allow him a potential saving from a curteous fellow - as avoiding Yoshi wouldn't make sense, expecially since he was aware of the medic possibly being him beforehand (More probably than anyone else). 

 

~Result: Unlikely~

 

How Axilus couldn't be a mafian: 

He actually thought I was alive. 

 

 

 

~~

JL: He hasn't been playing

 

 

I think you should vote both of them so I can watch them suffer. We'll burn their corpses in effigy while burning their real corpses. 

 

Butch, can we make a restriction on multi-votes next game? 

[I_Make_Big_Boom]

Delpen9 Caboose wasn't playing for most of the game (supposedly) and he ended up being Mafian. What sets Caboose and JL apart though is that JL has been moderately active in 5.0, while Caboose isn't (he's still a damn Mafian though).

 

Caboose claims he didn't even know he was Mafian the whole game, but that seems like a tactic to make the Pro-Towns believe that inactive players can't be Mafia (which they most certainly can be). The "He can't be Mafian because he's inactive" argument is void. Even if Caboose didn't even know he was Mafia.

 

And Yoshi I think it's apparent that either JL or Axilus is the Mafian (I'm leaning a little towards Axilus since he completely sidewinded my and Ledgend's evidence to prove he's guilty).

 

But like I said the smart move would be to kill both JL and Axilus. Better safe then sorry. This is the quickest route to Pro-Town victory.

[Axilus Prime]

I'll show you the evidence that Yoshi is medic when the game is over.

Of what relevance, Ledgend, would that be?

[Guts]

How Axilus could be a Mafian:

He killed Ledgend because he thought Yoshi was subterfuge; this would all make sense with Ledgend's unexpected saving in round 1. Ledgend may have been saved by the medic at first, but the possiblities lie in the medic defending himself. Attacking Yoshi would mean a waste of a round, and leaving him alone would allow him a potential saving from a curteous fellow - as avoiding Yoshi wouldn't make sense, expecially since he was aware of the medic possibly being him beforehand (More probably than anyone else). 

 

~Result: Unlikely~

 

How Axilus couldn't be a mafian: 

He actually thought I was alive. 

 

 

 

~~

JL: He hasn't been playing

 

 

I think you should vote both of them so I can watch them suffer. We'll burn their corpses in effigy while burning their real corpses. 

 

Butch, can we make a restriction on multi-votes next game?

Whoever hosts the next game can do that

[Caboose The Ace]

^

^

^

 

In all honesty I was on holiday for two weeks with no internet connection so I was out of the loop for most of the game.

 

Proof : Why did I suddenly not come onto the forum for two weeks...

Edited August 29, 2014 by Caboose The Ace

[Frankenzer]

Let's kill them all  

[Axilus Prime]

I don't think a restriction on multi-votes is needed, but I guess that depends on the next host.

[Delpen9]

Delpen9 Caboose wasn't playing for most of the game (supposedly) and he ended up being Mafian. What sets Caboose and JL apart though is that JL has been moderately active in 5.0, while Caboose isn't (he's still a damn Mafian though).

Caboose claims he didn't even know he was Mafian the whole game, but that seems like a tactic to make the Pro-Towns believe that inactive players can't be Mafia (which they most certainly can be). The "He can't be Mafian because he's inactive" argument is void. Even if Caboose didn't even know he was Mafia.

And Yoshi I think it's apparent that either JL or Axilus is the Mafian (I'm leaning a little towards Axilus since he completely sidewinded my and Ledgend's evidence to prove he's guilty).

But like I said the smart move would be to kill both JL and Axilus. Better safe then sorry. This is the quickest route to Pro-Town victory.

 

I didn't defend or support JL. I really don't care about this.

[Rue]

Blarg.